The buying and selling relationship between the U.S., Mexico, and Canada is an important set of commerce relations for all three nations. Canada and Mexico are the US’ first and second largest export markets with items exports of $680 billion in 2023, and the U.S. is the most important export marketplace for Canada and Mexico. Exports among the many U.S., Mexico, and Canada help over 17 million jobs.
The buying and selling relationship among the many U.S., Canada, and Mexico is underpinned by the United States-Mexico-Canada Settlement (USMCA), a brand new commerce settlement that changed NAFTA and was negotiated and finalized in the course of the first Trump administration. But, on February 1, 2025, President Trump imposed 25% tariffs (which have been subsequently delayed for Mexico by one month) on imports from Canada and Mexico and 10% tariffs on power imports from Canada to handle flows of fentanyl and unlawful migration. Mexico and Canada have indicated they’re making ready retaliatory tariffs, and Trump has said that he’ll elevate U.S. tariffs additional in response. The distinction within the unfavorable financial affect from the present 10% tariff on power imports versus a 25% tariff is comparatively small. And provided that Canada and Mexico look nearly sure to retaliate, doubtless resulting in even larger U.S. tariffs, the next assesses the affect of across-the-board 25% tariffs.
The affect of those tariffs on commerce throughout North America shall be notably impactful, not solely due to the big quantity of commerce that’s concerned, but in addition due to the significance of provide chains, which comprise round 50% of intraregional commerce. For instance, within the manufacturing of a Chevy Silverado or Dodge Challenger, elements cross borders a number of occasions earlier than being assembled right into a remaining product. In consequence, imposing a 25% tariff each time a product crosses borders provides up shortly.
The next presents the outcomes of simulations based mostly on the World Commerce Evaluation Challenge (GTAP) mannequin beneath two situations. The primary situation assesses the financial impacts on the U.S., Mexico, and Canada with the U.S. imposing across-the-board 25% tariffs on imports from Mexico and Canada with no retaliation from Canada or Mexico. The second situation assesses the affect of Canada and Mexico retaliating with 25% tariffs on U.S. imports. All financial impacts are estimated to happen over the medium time period (i.e., over the subsequent three to 5 years). Provided that U.S. tariffs on imports from Mexico and Canada beneath USMCA are most often near zero now, a 25% tariff may have vital unfavorable financial shocks for the U.S., Mexico, and Canada. In each situations, the financial affect is extra extreme for Mexico and Canada as a result of a a lot bigger share of their commerce is with the U.S.—83% of Mexico’s exports and 78% of Canada’s exports go to the U.S., whereas round one-third of U.S. exports are destined for Canada and Mexico. That mentioned, the financial hit to the U.S. is substantial, with some sectors particularly standing to contract considerably.
These tariffs may even hurt the Trump administration’s aim of creating safer provide chains and competing with China. Persevering with to make progress right here would require better commerce and funding throughout North America to strengthen and diversify current provide chains and scale back reliance on China-centered provide chains. The tariffs are straight at odds with deeper financial integration throughout North America. The truth is, China will profit from a commerce struggle throughout North America, because it undercuts efforts to reshore provide chains away from China. Extra broadly, as a result of these tariffs are most certainly inconsistent with USMCA, they sign to the world that any worldwide settlement with the U.S. just isn’t value all that a lot, elevating tough questions for all U.S. allies and buying and selling companions in regards to the worth of commerce agreements with the U.S. One result’s that nations will begin to hedge—creating new choices for commerce and funding to insure in opposition to an unreliable U.S., which is able to embody being extra open to increasing commerce and funding relations with China.
Impression of tariffs on financial progress
Determine 1 exhibits that tariffs would cut back U.S. GDP progress by round 0.25 share factors, and with retaliation, U.S. GDP progress falls over 0.3 share factors. With U.S. GDP in 2024 of roughly $23.5 trillion, this quantities to an estimated lack of U.S. financial output over the medium time period of round $45 billion from the 25% on imports from Canada and Mexico, and this rises to about $75 billion in misplaced financial output ought to Canada and Mexico retaliate. As could be seen, losses to financial progress for Canada and Mexico are round 1.15 share factors from the 25% U.S. tariffs, and this will increase to over 3 share factors ought to they each impose 25% tariffs on U.S. imports.
Determine 1
Impression of tariffs on jobs and wages
The tariffs will take a toll on employment in all three nations. Determine 2 exhibits the job losses from tariffs. Within the U.S., employment will decline by 0.11% from the 25% tariffs on imports and rise to a 0.25% lack of jobs with retaliation. Primarily based on 2024 job information, that is equal to over 177,000 job losses from the 25% tariff, rising to over 400,000 job losses within the occasion Canada and Mexico retaliate. Job losses in Canada and Mexico could be round 1.3% and a couple of.3%, respectively, and based mostly on 2024 jobs numbers, this may quantity to 278,000 Canadian jobs and 1.4 million Mexican jobs. Within the occasion of retaliation, job loses would improve to nearly 2.5% and three.6% of whole employment in Canada and Mexico, equal to over 510,000 Canadian jobs and a couple of.2 million Mexican jobs.
Determine 2
Tariffs may even result in decrease wages throughout the three nations. Within the U.S., wages would decline by 0.2%, and by 0.5% within the occasion of retaliation. In Canada, wages would fall by over 2.6% and in Mexico by over 4.5% within the situation of no retaliation, and by 4.9% and over 7% in Canada and Mexico following retaliation by each nations. Price noting right here is that the contraction in demand for labor and decline in wages could be distributed evenly throughout expert and unskilled labor, however with a barely larger affect on unskilled labor.
Impression of tariffs on exports
The affect from tariffs on exports proven in Determine 3 would even be massive. U.S. exports to Canada and Mexico would decline by round 6% from a 25% U.S. tariff, and 9% within the case of retaliation. Exports from Canada to the U.S. and Mexico would contract by 9% with a U.S. tariff, and by 19% with retaliatory tariffs. Mexico’s exports would contract by near 14% and over 25% with retaliatory tariffs.
Determine 3
Impression of tariffs on inflation
As seen in Determine 4, tariffs would additionally have an effect on inflation. The tariffs would trigger inflation to rise within the U.S. by over 1.3 share factors. With retaliation, the inflation improve within the U.S. could be much less at round 0.8 share factors, however nonetheless vital, reflecting the better slowdown in U.S. financial progress. Within the case of Canada, inflation would decline as U.S. tariffs decrease financial progress, however ought to Canada then impose 25% tariffs, inflation would improve, reflecting the affect on the worth of imports from the U.S. Within the case of Mexico, there may be additionally vital decline in inflation of 9% following U.S. tariffs, reflecting the affect of decrease financial progress, and this decline is lowered to round 6 share factors ought to Mexico put a 25% tariff on U.S. imports.
Determine 4
Sectoral impacts of tariffs
The outcomes introduced earlier present the affect on the combination economies. The unfavorable affect on exports is broadly dispersed throughout sectors, the underside line being that every one three nations expertise vital sector-wide contractions in exports.
The next presents a few of the sector-specific commerce outcomes. Provided that there are not any tariffs proposed between Canada and Mexico, and because the overwhelming majority of their exports are to the U.S., the next evaluation focuses on the impacts on U.S. exports to Canada and Mexico, and the impacts on Canadian and Mexican exports to the U.S. To begin, the trinational integration of most of the sectors via provide chains implies that most of the sectors affected by these tariffs are frequent throughout the three nations. Furthermore, most of the sectors affected produce manufacturing and different enterprise inputs, similar to metals, computer systems, and equipment tools. Elevating the prices of those exports will subsequently improve prices for companies in all nations, decreasing their competitiveness, and lead many companies to as an alternative supply inputs from different nations, together with these in Asia.
Within the U.S. for instance, as proven in Desk 1, exports throughout mining, manufacturing, lumber, and metals would all undergo massive contractions in exports. U.S. mining exports to Canada undergo an nearly 60% decline in exports, and following retaliation, U.S. mining exports are nearly fully worn out, with a 97% contraction. There’s a 25% contraction in U.S. motorcar exports to Canada that will increase to 55% with retaliation, and merchandise in “different transport” fall by 18% following U.S. tariffs and by 79% with retaliation. Within the electrical tools sector, the 12% decline in exports from {the electrical} sector will flip right into a 30% plus decline with retaliation.
Desk 1
Desk 2 exhibits that U.S. exports to Mexico additionally fall throughout manufacturing, lumber, meals, and metals particularly, however nearly each sector experiences a big contraction in exports. For instance, U.S. exports of nonferrous metals similar to copper, aluminum, zinc, and gold decline by 35% following the U.S. tariffs after which by 78% with retaliation by Mexico. U.S. exports of manufactured merchandise—computer systems and electronics, motor automobiles, digital tools, different transport—all undergo massive declines. For instance, there’s a 31% decline in exports of computer systems and electronics, and with retaliation, these U.S. exports fall by over 80%. Exports of motor automobiles additionally decline by 23% with tariffs after which by 65% following retaliation.
Desk 2
Desk 3 exhibits a few of the key sectors the place Canada’s exports to the U.S. would contract throughout manufacturing, mining, textiles, rubber, and plastics. For instance, exports of digital tools and electronics decline by over 70% following U.S. tariffs and by near 80% with retaliatory tariffs. Exports of “different transport” decline by 70% with tariffs and 74% with retaliation, and motorcar exports from Canada decline by 53% with the U.S. tariffs and by 68% with retaliatory tariffs. The highest 5 contraction in Canada’s exports.
Desk 3
The decline in exports from Mexico are throughout mining, the auto sector, electrical tools, rubber and attire, and textiles. As an illustration, Mexico’s mining sector exports undergo contractions of over 90%. The pharmaceutical sector additionally contracts over 60% with tariffs and over 70% following retaliation. Mexico’s exports of motorcar and digital tools sectors additionally contract considerably, a standard consequence for all three nations given the provision chains in these sectors, with exports falling 40% and 55%, respectively, and with the retaliation, exports of those merchandise fall by 50% and 62%.
Desk 4
Conclusion
The U.S. tariff of 25% on imports from Canada and Mexico goes to scale back U.S. financial progress, scale back jobs, trigger wages to fall, and costs to rise, and retaliation by Canada and Mexico will multiply the financial harms throughout the three nations. President Trump has mentioned that these tariffs are in response to flows of fentanyl and unlawful immigrants from Mexico and Canada. The issue with these tariffs is that they impose quick prices on U.S. shoppers, employees, and companies with out a clear hyperlink between these tariffs and the way they’ll scale back flows of immigrants or fentanyl.
Furthermore, these tariffs will hurt the Trump administration’s aim of creating safer provide chains and competing with China. Extra broadly, as a result of these tariffs are most certainly inconsistent with USMCA, nations will begin to hedge—creating new choices for commerce and funding to insure in opposition to an unreliable U.S., which is able to embody being extra open to increasing commerce and funding relations with China.
Except the Trump administration resolves its points with Canada and Mexico and unwinds these tariffs shortly, the financial, diplomatic, and strategic harms from the tariffs shall be substantial.
The Brookings Establishment is dedicated to high quality, independence, and affect.
We’re supported by a various array of funders. In keeping with our values and insurance policies, every Brookings publication represents the only real views of its writer(s).
